Tarantella Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria

Reviews

• Pren N.

  star star star star star 8 July 2026

  The best italian restaurant and pizza in rockland
  Thank you for service
  This is one of the best place !
  
  Italuan restaurant and pizzeria you can have in this area nyack ny

• Ron P.

  star star star star_border star_border 6 July 2026

  We stopped in for a quick lunch in between visits at nearby Nyack Hospital. Ordered at the counter and took the slices into the 1950's era dining room. Pizza was good despite the pepperoni slice dripping in pepperoni oil.
  
  All in all, a good place to grab a slice.

• Nathalie E.

  star star star star_border star_border 30 June 2026

  The first time my coworker and I order her it was delicious we all ordered the chicken wings it was nicely cooked and the blue cheese was amazing. So we thought since we enjoyed it so much the first time we would do it again, bad idea. They not only messed up a couple of orders but they forgot one so not one of my coworker didn't have any food because by the time they came back to give it to her her lunch was over . I'm one to always give a place a 2nd try after they mess up solely on the fact that nobody perfect and they did such a good job the first time that last time was just a back night. Well we were once again mistaken the food that was made correctly was amazing yes but once again food was forgotten and mistaken. Please management as good as your food are there has to be some consistency when it come to your restaurant and deliver.

• Elaine K.

  star star star star star_border 21 June 2026

  On good dry weather days, restaurants should take advantage and setup their outdoor seatings/tables for guests with pets. So glad to have found this place that can accommodate us. Enjoyed a quick lunch with our furry-kid. I had cheese-less a slice of chicken parm/veggie pizza, while hubby had slices of chicken buffalo and bacon ranch. All were yummy!
  Will definitely be our goto place when walking with our Brody .

• Christianna L.

  star star star star_border star_border 17 June 2026

  If you ask Nyack regulars, you'll get some pretty strong opinions on which is better: Tarantella or Turiello's. There's a friendly neighborhood rivalry between the two, although both have stood for close to twenty years.
  
  The pizza is tasty - the crust does tend toward the chewy. The sauce is fresh, the cheese is fine. The staff is friendly and accommodating.  
  
  For my part, I prefer Tarantella just a smidge more, no small part due to the location. I'm more often closer to Broadway than Main St. and I'd rather stop in here than walk the five blocks up the road to Turiello's. The space is much brighter, I'm just that much more likely to choose to settle in here for a slice of pizza and Diet Coke after a hike in Nyack Beach State Park.